Vinyl, fiber cement, wood, and metal are the four types of siding most homeowners choose between. Vinyl wins on price, fiber cement on resale value, wood on looks, and metal on longevity. The right pick depends on your budget, climate, and storm exposure.
Most siding guides stop at cost and curb appeal. At Storm Guard Roofing, we inspect, repair, and replace all four materials, so we see firsthand which ones crack, dent, or blow after severe weather. Use this framework to compare house siding on cost, lifespan, maintenance, and storm durability before you commit to your project.
Choosing the right type of siding for your home depends on your budget, local weather, and how much maintenance you are willing to do. Most siding options can look good on day one. However, the difference shows after 10 years or following a big storm.
Upfront price and total cost of ownership are two different numbers. A cheaper material that needs panel replacements after every hailstorm or repainting every few years often costs more over 20 years than a premium option. If you plan to sell your home in the near future, prioritize resale value over maximum lifespan.
Your local weather narrows the field quickly. Vinyl can turn brittle in extreme cold and warp near intense heat. Wood struggles in a damp, humid climate where rot and insects thrive. In hail-prone areas, impact resistance should sit at the top of your list. Our team can walk you through the siding styles we install and which ones are best suited to your region.
Pick a color for how it will look in 15 years, not for this season’s trend. Light and earthy shades reflect sunlight and fade more slowly than dark tones. Test large sample boards directly against your home in the morning, at noon, and at dusk to see how the undertones interact with your roof, brick, and trim. Always confirm HOA guidelines before placing your final order.
The four main types of exterior siding are vinyl, fiber cement, wood (including engineered wood), and metal. Each type comes in different styles, so you can choose both the material and the design separately.
Vinyl is the most widely used siding on new homes,accounting for 26% of homes, according to U.S. Census Bureau data from the National Association of Home Builders. It is affordable, rot-proof, and easy to maintain with a garden hose. Modern offers versatile options that mimic clapboard, shake, and vertical panels.
However, vinyl can fade in strong sunlight, warp near high heat, or crack from impact in cold weather. For extra strength, insulated vinyl adds a foam backing that stiffens the panels and improves your home’s comfort.
Made from cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, fiber cement is a major step up from vinyl. Leading options like James Hardie’s HardiePlank® are noncombustible and feature a 30-year warranty. It resists rot, termites, and impact. Because of its weight, installation requires precision, and you will need to repaint periodically unless you select a factory finish.
Natural wood, especially cedar, offers the warmest look and flexibility in custom colors. It also needs the most upkeep: regular sealing or painting, plus vigilance against rot, woodpeckers, and insects. Engineered wood, like LP® SmartSide®, mimics that authentic look while offering superior moisture resistance, greater durability, and a simpler installation.
Steel and aluminum siding resist fire, rot, and pests and need little maintenance. Steel stands up well to wind and impact. Aluminum dents easily, and older aluminum fades, making it difficult to match a single replacement panel.
You can also have other options, such as brick, stucco, and stone veneer. These masonry systems offer exceptional durability, but expect higher costs and heavier structural demands than panel siding. Below is a quick summary of the types to guide your decision:
| Material | Upfront cost | Maintenance | Storm durability | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vinyl | Lowest | Low | Fair: can crack in hail and cold | Tight budgets, mild climates |
| Fiber cement | Mid to high | Low to moderate (periodic repaint) | Strong: resists impact, fire, and rot | Storm-prone areas, resale value |
| Wood and engineered wood | Mid to high | High for natural wood | Moderate: engineered wood holds up better | Natural look, historic homes |
| Metal (steel, aluminum) | Mid to high | Low | Steel is strong; aluminum dents | Longevity, high-wind areas |
Vinyl is the least expensive siding to install, fiber cement and wood sit in the middle to upper range, and metal and premium wood are the most expensive.
Installed siding is priced per square foot, with professional labor making up a major share of your total investment. Beyond raw materials, these key factors move your overall estimate the most:
| Factor | Impact on cost |
|---|---|
| Material and product line | High |
| Wall area and number of stories | High |
| Removal and disposal of old siding | Medium |
| Sheathing and house wrap repairs | Low to high, depending on what is found |
| Trim, corners, and window details | Medium |
| Permits and site access | Low |
Always ask for itemized quotes that separate material, labor, tear-off, and trim so you can compare bids line by line.
Despite the upfront cost, new siding is a smart investment that pays for itself. Fiber cement replacement recoups 113.7% of its cost at resale, while vinyl recovers 96.5%. Whichever material fits your budget, upgrading your exterior builds immediate curb appeal and lasting value.
Not sure which material fits your home and budget? Contact Storm Guard Roofing in your area and schedule a trusted consultation!
Most siding lasts 20 to 60 years, depending on the material, the installation quality, and how hard your climate is on it.
The table below reflects real-world service lives. For well-maintained siding, theInterNACHI home life-expectancy chart estimates even longer lifespans, up to 60 years for vinyl and 100 years or more for fiber cement.
| Material | Typical lifespan | What shortens it |
|---|---|---|
| Vinyl | 20 to 40 years | UV fading, heat warping, hail cracks |
| Fiber cement | 40 to 50+ years | Poor flashing, unsealed cut edges |
| Wood | 20 to 40 years with upkeep | Moisture, rot, insects, skipped sealing |
| Metal | 40 to 60+ years | Dents, scratches that lead to rust |
For every material, the same factors shorten life: constant sun, trapped moisture, clogged gutters, poor installation, and storm damage.
In fact, improper installation does more than shorten performance; it is also the most common way to void your siding warranty. Major brands like James Hardie and CertainTeed require strict adherence to building codes and written instructions. Unapproved painting or uncertified labor can also invalidate coverage. Always review your warranty terms before starting any maintenance, painting, or repairs.
Fiber cement and steel are the best materials for resisting hail and strong winds. Vinyl is most likely to crack, and aluminum is most likely to dent. If you live in an area that experiences severe weather often, it’s important to consider this ranking more than the cost.
Every siding material reacts differently under severe weather pressure:
Wind performance relies heavily on both fastening and materials. Panels must be nailed according to the manufacturer’s guidelines, and vinyl should have space to expand. For vinyl, look for products certified by the Vinyl Siding Institute (VSI) to comply with ASTM D3679 standards for weatherability, impact resistance, and wind load. Always check a product’s wind rating against your local building codes.
Siding damage often appears alongside roof damage, so check both after a storm. Look for cracked or dented panels on the sides that faced the storm, dents in gutters and downspouts, and torn window screens. Our guide on how to know if hail has damaged your roof walks through a safe ground-level check.
Storm Guard Roofing inspects and documents damage, providing your insurer with a written report and photos. Our team is also available to meet with the adjuster on-site to discuss the details. Coverage and deductibles vary, so review your policy with your insurer. If you are replacing damaged siding anyway, ask about upgrading to a more impact-resistant material. Learn more about storm and hail damage repair.
Annual cleaning and inspection help keep most siding healthy, and replacement makes sense once damage is widespread or keeps recurring. Small, isolated problems usually call for a repair.
Simple, regular upkeep protects your investment and keeps your siding performing at its best year after year.
Knowing what to look for helps you catch siding failure early and protect your home from hidden moisture damage.
If damage covers more than a few panels, or the material is discontinued and cannot be matched, full replacement usually costs less over time than patching. Storm Guard Roofing can inspect your walls and give you advice on which is the right choice between repair and replacement.
Are you comparing types of siding materials or dealing with storm damage? A professional inspection shows what your walls need and which siding will hold up where you live. Find your local Storm Guard Roofing team and schedule a trusted consultation today!
Vinyl is the most popular siding on new US homes. It was the principal exterior material on 26 percent of homes started in 2024, per Census data reported by NAHB, because it is the least expensive to install and needs little maintenance. Fiber cement is a common upgrade for more durability and resale value.
Fiber cement and steel are the most durable mainstream options. Fiber cement resists fire, rot, insects, and impact and typically lasts 40 to 50 years or more. Steel resists cracking in cold and high winds. Vinyl is the least impact-resistant and cracks most easily in hail.
Vinyl is the cheapest siding to buy and install, followed by aluminum and engineered wood. The trade-off is a shorter lifespan and lower impact resistance, so the lowest upfront price is not always the lowest cost over 20 years, once repairs and replacements are factored in.
Vinyl lasts roughly 20 to 40 years; fiber cement, 40 to 50 or more; wood, 20 to 40 with upkeep; and metal, 40 to 60 or more. Keep in mind that sun, moisture, poor installation, and storms all shorten those ranges, which is why installation quality matters as much as the material.
Fiber cement and steel hold up best to hail and wind because they resist cracking and denting. Vinyl is the most likely to crack in a hailstorm, and aluminum dents. If your area sees frequent storms, upgrading to an impact-resistant material during replacement is worth considering.
Yes. Many homes combine materials, for example, fiber cement lap siding on the main walls with shake or board-and-batten accents on the gables. Mixing adds curb appeal and lets you invest in durability where the home is most exposed to weather.
Unless otherwise noted, each use of "Storm Guard," “us,” “we,” or “our” throughout Stormguardrc.com collectively refers to both the Storm Guard brand and the Storm Guard Franchise System, which is made up almost exclusively of independently owned and operated franchise locations.
