Ads Pixel
Home / Resources / Siding Resources & Home Improvement Tips | Storm Guard / Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement: Which Siding Is Best for You?

Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement: Which Siding Is Best for You?

By Storm Guard
new soffit and vinyl siding

Overwhelmed by siding choices? From classic to modern types, with numerous options available, choosing the best siding for a home can be paralyzing. Every siding material has its own pros and cons, making it challenging to determine which one is right for you.

This blog is a practical guide to comparing types of siding, focusing on cost, durability, aesthetics, and weather performance. We’ll provide a side-by-side siding types comparison, including pro tips to help you choose confidently.

What Should You Consider Before Choosing Siding?

When you opt for a new siding, you’re investing in your home’s durability, curb appeal, and longer lifespan. So, what are the considerations you should weigh? Here are the top factors to consider:

vinyl siding installation
  • Climate and weather exposure: Living in extreme weather conditions or high-wind-prone areas requires opting for durable siding that can withstand the elements. 
  • Budget: Consider the initial and long-term expenses, including maintenance and potential repairs. 
  • Maintenance preference: Decide whether you want a low-maintenance siding or prefer routine cleaning and upkeep.
  • Architectural style: Select a siding style that complements your home’s overall design, taking into account its roof, walls, windows, columns, and other exterior features.
  • Resale value: Think of how your choice of siding styles and materials will affect your home’s resale value. 

Vinyl Siding

Looking for a siding option that won’t leave your wallet empty? Then vinyl siding is right up your alley! But what exactly makes this siding material so appealing to homeowners who don’t want to break the bank?

  • Affordable upfront cost
  • Low maintenance requirement
  • Easy to install
  • Wide range of colors and styles
  • Fewer repairs needed over time

Of course, siding options aren’t always perfect, and vinyl siding has its drawbacks. Here are a few things you need to consider:

  • Less durable under impact than other siding materials
  • Can fade or become brittle over time
  • May not have the same classic look as natural wood

Overall, considering the vinyl siding pros and cons, it is a great choice for homeowners who want a cost-effective, low-maintenance solution that still delivers on curb appeal. With its many benefits and few drawbacks, it’s definitely worth considering for your next home improvement project.

Fiber Cement Siding

Are you looking for a resilient siding material? Fiber cement might be the siding for your home. This durable siding is made from a mixture of Portland cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. But here’s what exactly makes this siding material so appealing: 

  • Highly durable and resistant to weather damage, high winds, and fire
  • Offers a wood-like look without the high-maintenance requirements for real wood 

Like the other siding materials, fiber cement siding is not without its drawbacks. Some potential downsides you should know include:

  • Heavier than the other siding materials, which can make installation more challenging
  • Higher upfront costs compared to other siding options
  • May require occasional paint touch-ups to maintain its color and appearance

While the fiber cement siding cost may be higher upfront, its added durability and longer life can make it a cost-effective choice in the long run. With few repairs, fiber cement siding can be a wise investment for homeowners living in storm-prone areas.

Engineered Wood Siding

Do you want to achieve the warm, inviting look of natural wood on your home’s style without the hefty price tag? Then, an engineered wood siding might be the one you’re looking for. Here are some key benefits you’ll enjoy when you opt for this siding material:

Brown wooden siding on a house
  • Lighter than fiber cement siding, making it easier to install
  • Offers a natural wood look 
  • More affordable than real wood, without sacrificing aesthetics

Of course, just like the other siding materials, engineered wood siding has its disadvantages. Here are some potential downsides you need to know before making the final call:

  • Can be prone to moisture damage without proper sealing
  • May require frequent maintenance than other siding materials

Engineered wood siding is ideal for homeowners who want the classic look of wood on their home exterior without the high cost of real wood. With proper installation and maintenance, engineered wood can be an excellent siding choice. 

Metal Siding (Steel or Aluminum)

If you’re looking for a siding that can withstand the harshest weather conditions, metal siding might be the one for you. Here are some key advantages of metal siding over other materials to help you make a better siding types comparison:

  • Fire-resistant and suitable for areas prone to wildfires
  • Strong against storms and can withstand high winds
  • Low maintenance requirements, less upkeep cost
  • Great for modern-style homes with contemporary design detail

Metal siding also comes with its own set of challenges. To name a few, here are some potential downsides you may have to consider:

  • Can dent or scratch, compromising its appearance
  • May not reach its full aesthetic potential when installed in traditional homes

Despite these potential drawbacks, metal siding is ideal for homeowners who prioritize durability and low maintenance. With its added durability and longer life, metal siding can be a great fit for your home.

Natural Wood Siding 

natural wood siding

Everyone can agree that there is something special about the warm look of natural wood siding. It’s a classic choice that can add curb appeal and character to any home. Enjoy these key benefits when you choose natural wood for your home siding: 

  • Timeless beauty that can increase your home’s value
  • Customizable with stains and paints to match your unique interests
  • An ideal siding choice for traditional or rustic-style homes 

As beautiful as it is, natural wood siding requires a lot of tender love and care to keep it looking its best. Some of its drawbacks include: 

  • High maintenance requirements, including routine cleaning and sealing
  • Susceptible to rot, insects, and fire, which can compromise its durability

Natural wood siding is recommended for homeowners who prioritize curb appeal and are willing to invest time and money into maintenance. It may be more susceptible to rot, mold, and termites, but with proper care, homeowners can increase the longevity of their natural wood siding.

Side-by-Side Comparison Chart

You’re about to embark on a siding installation or replacement project, but you’re not sure which siding material fits your wants and needs. To help you make informed decisions, here’s a comparison chart highlighting various materials’ key benefits and features. 

Siding MaterialInitial CostLifespanMaintenance NeedsDurabilityStyle OptionsROI/Resale Impact
Vinyl Siding$8,000 – $16,00020-30 yearsLow maintenanceModerateVarious colors and styles70-80%
Fiber Cement Siding$10,000 – $25,00030-50 yearsAverage maintenanceVery HighDurable siding with a wood-like look80-90%
Engineered Wood Siding$7,000 – $22,00020-30 yearsLow maintenanceHighRealistic wood look70%
Metal Siding$8,000 – $32,00030-50 yearsLow maintenanceVery HighModern look and durable80-90%
Natural Wood Siding$19,300 – $45,17520-30 yearsHigh maintenanceModerateClassic look and customizable90-100%

Whether you prioritize cost effectiveness, durability, or style, this chart can help you choose the right siding for your home. 

So, Which Siding Is Right for You? 

A detailed siding comparison can help you choose which material is the best fit for your home’s style and personal taste. However, you can further narrow down your choices by asking yourself these few key questions.

Ask YourselfBest Fit
Are you budget-conscious?Vinyl Siding
Do you live in storm-heavy regions?Fiber Cement Siding or Metal Siding
Are you looking for a traditional aesthetic?Natural Wood Siding or Engineered Wood Siding

Choosing a siding that suits your home’s style and needs requires careful consideration. However, with detailed comparisons of siding types and professional guidance, the process can be manageable. Every home and budget has a great match—you need the facts and a trusted team.

Simplify Your Siding Choice—Your Local Siding Guide Is Ready to Help 

At Storm Guard, we’re a trusted and reliable provider of siding installation services. We enjoy helping homeowners like you find the best possible solution for their needs. Schedule a free siding consultation with us today. 

Still unsure what siding works best for your home and climate? Talk to your local Storm Guard for honest advice and a no-obligation quote. 

Find your Location

FIND YOUR LOCATION

Enter your Zip Code to find your location

KEEP READING

© 2026 Storm Guard Franchise Systems LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Unless otherwise noted, each use of "Storm Guard," “us,” “we,” or “our” throughout Stormguardrc.com collectively refers to both the Storm Guard brand and the Storm Guard Franchise System, which is made up almost exclusively of independently owned and operated franchise locations.